- Home
- >
- Side by side comparison
Compare Top Rated Mattresses
Before selecting a new mattress, use our comparison tool to evaluate the top-rated options based on key features like comfort, support, and durability. Compare up to three mattresses by clicking on the icons below to find the perfect fit for your sleep needs.
We've compared top brands to help you make more confident choices.
Add a brand
Compare up to three brands
Add a brand
Compare up to three brands
Add a brand
Compare up to three brands
- mattress typeMemory Foam
- firmness6.5
- modelNectar Classic
- materialsPolyfoam, Gel-infused foam
- height12'' Height
- layers5 Layers
- mattress typeHybrid
- firmness6
- modelDreamCloud Hybrid
- materialsSoft polyfoam
- height12'' Height
- layers8 Layers
- mattress typeInnerspring
- firmness7.5
- modelSaatva Classic
- materialsOrganic cotton
- height11.5" Height
- layers5 Layers
- mattress typeMemory Foam
- firmness6.5
- modelNectar Classic
- materialsPolyfoam, Gel-infused foam
- height12'' Height
- layers5 Layers
- mattress typeMemory Foam
- firmness6.5
- modelSiena Memory Foam
- materials3-layer memory foam
- height10'' Height
- layers5 Layers
- mattress typeHybrid
- firmness6.7
- modelHelix Midnight
- materialsPolyfoam
- height11.5'' Height
- layers5 Layers
Price
Price
Price
Price
Price
Price
Pros & Cons
Comfortable for all average-weight sleeper types- Classic memory foam feel, with deep sinkage and contouring
- 365-Day sleep trial and warranty
- Free shipping and delivery
- Absorbs motion, making it ideal for couples
Stomach sleepers might not get the best support- Doesn't support sleepers over 250 pounds
Pros & Cons
- Great for back- and side sleepers
- Suitable for couples & heavier builds
- Premium edge support for people with limited mobility
- 365-night trial
- Lifetime defect warranty
- Combines comfort & support
- Limited sinking
- Heavy & difficult to move
Pros & Cons
- High-quality, USA-based manufacturing
- Customizable firmness
- CertiPUR-US certified foam
- Industry-leading warranty terms
- Exceptional point-pressure relief
- Luxurious, supportive pillow-top cover
- Superb edge support
- Not a bed-in-a-box service
- Not the cheapest option
Pros & Cons
- Comfortable for all average-weight sleeper types
- Classic memory foam feel, with deep sinkage and contouring
- 365-Day sleep trial and warranty
- Free shipping and delivery
- Absorbs motion, making it ideal for couples
- Stomach sleepers might not get the best support
- Doesn't support sleepers over 250 pounds
Pros & Cons
- Budget friendly
- 180-night sleep trial
- Free shipping & returns
- Quality construction
- Not ideal for light sleepers
Pros & Cons
- Fully customizable mattress
- 3 levels of firmness
- USA made
- Lacks custom memory foam option
- Not the cheapest option
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Rating
Purchase terms
- America's Favorite
- Free Shipping & Returns
- 365 Night Trial
- Forever Warranty
Purchase terms
- Free Shipping & Returns
- 365 Night Trial
- Lifetime Warranty
- Financing Available
Purchase terms
- Made in USA
- Free Delivery & Setup
- 365 Night Trial
- Lifetime Warranty
- Financing Available
Purchase terms
- America's Favorite
- Free Shipping & Returns
- 365 Night Trial
- Forever Warranty
Purchase terms
- Free Shipping & Returns
- 180 Night Trial
- 10 Year Warranty
- Financing Available
Purchase terms
- Made in USA
- 120 Night Trial
- Lifetime Warranty
- Financing Available
Properties
- Cooling properties2
- Pressure relief9
- Responsiveness9
- Motion isolation8
- Firmness6.5
All score are on a scale of 1-10
Properties
- Cooling properties2
- Pressure relief9
- Responsiveness9
- Motion isolation5
- Firmness6
All score are on a scale of 1-10
Properties
- Cooling properties3
- Pressure relief8
- Responsiveness7
- Motion isolation9
- Firmness7.5
All score are on a scale of 1-10
Properties
- Cooling properties2
- Pressure relief9
- Responsiveness9
- Motion isolation8
- Firmness6.5
All score are on a scale of 1-10
Properties
- Cooling properties3
- Pressure relief9
- Responsiveness9
- Motion isolation10
- Firmness6.5
All score are on a scale of 1-10
Properties
- Cooling properties8
- Pressure relief8
- Responsiveness8
- Motion isolation9
- Firmness6.7
All score are on a scale of 1-10
Suitable for
Hot Sleepers- Side Sleepers
- Couples
- Motion Isolation
Edge Support- For Kids
Suitable for
- Hot Sleepers
- Side Sleepers
- Couples
- Motion Isolation
- Edge Support
- For Kids
Suitable for
- Hot Sleepers
- Side Sleepers
- Couples
- Motion Isolation
- Edge Support
- For Kids
Suitable for
- Hot Sleepers
- Side Sleepers
- Couples
- Motion Isolation
- Edge Support
- For Kids
Suitable for
- Hot Sleepers
- Side Sleepers
- Couples
- Motion Isolation
- Edge Support
- For Kids
Suitable for
- Hot Sleepers
- Side Sleepers
- Couples
- Motion Isolation
- Edge Support
- For Kids
User Reviews
Average User Rating
FIBROMYALGIA MIRACLE
I have suffered from fibromyalgia for years and the Nectar Mattress is the ONLY mattress that gives me a wonderful night's sleep! I highly recommend it, best investment I have ever made!!
DOING GOOD
DOING GOOD My wife and I were a bit skeptical, but wanted to try something different. I have been sleeping fine since day in, my wife woke with back pain the first two nights. She now says she is sleeping and feeling good!
MY RESEARCH PAID OFF!
I cannot believe how wonderful this bed is. I have been looking for awhile, having researched the Nectar. I just finally purchased it. After a week, it has been blissful sleep. I'd truly recommend the Nectar.
User Reviews
Average User Rating
Dreamcloud Mattress
For the past 11 years I've enjoyed my Tempur-pedic, but with age I started waking with lower back stiffness and pain. I read about the DreamCloud hybrid mattresses having more firmness while still offering a soft foam feel, so I bought one. It took a couple weeks to adjust, but I have noticed less pain and I fall asleep faster.
Searched for nine months
I purchased mine from city mattress. Joseph in Boynton Beach Florida, gave me an incredible deal. Comparing this company to mattress firm is a joke. I don't even know how mattress firm, is even in business? Horrible company in comparison. I researched for nine months. Never knew this mattress even existed, until I went to the store to purchase the nectar. I immediately fell in love with the queen size, as soon as I laid on it. I always do extensive research before making any purchase. Even after laying on some of the beds that were 3 to 4 times more expensive, I found this bed to be just as worthy. Also looking at their warranty, it was a no-brainer. When receiving free white glove delivery. I asked the delivery guy about the mattress. He stated, that he has never pick one of these up after delivering it. He said that "this mattress is the best, out of every mattress in the box he has delivered. In the three years that he has been making deliveries with these types of mattresses. It's been about a month, and all my pain is gone! From day one, that this mattress was delivered! Never have I slept so good. I don't even wanna get out of the bed. I can sleep 10 hours no problem. Previously, I couldn't get more than five hours worth of sleep without tossing and turning every hour. I am 51 years old, with a lot of back and knee injuries. I honestly did not even know that this was a bed in the box, when purchasing it. I also received an adjustable bedframe for free. My total cost was $1068. I rate this bed 10 out of 10!!!!
Love, Love my bed!!!!!
We have tried every bed imaginable we love our Dreamcloud, It is firm yet soft enough to conform to your body. Worth every penny would buy again we have had ours for about 10 months.
User Reviews
Average User Rating
Fantastic mattress...
I purchased a Saatva mattress five years ago. This is by far the best mattress I ever purchased. I work in freight business, physical labor. and after a long day, sleep and rest is so important. I purchased the medium mattress, and it is not to hard, nor soft, and I totally relax for a great nites sleep.. After 5 years, its as comfortable as the day I purchased it.. Definitely recommend this great mattress, its well worth the price you pay..
Excellent mattress/ Superb customer service !
Their customer service is superb ! I decided that I needed to change my Classic Queen Plush soft for a Classic Queen Luxury Firm. ( I am 6' 210 lbs ). The Saatva service rep. (Lelia) was extremely knowledgeable, helpful and considerate. They immediately authorized the exchange. I could not be more pleased with this company.
Cudos
I originally purchased a memory foam mattress from another highly rated company. After a couple of weeks I was totally disappointed with the level of support it offered. After doing a lot of research I decided to go with the Saatva Luxury Firm Queen. I could not be happier with the overall comfort and support the mattress delivers. I also fell it offers outstanding value.
User Reviews
No reviews just yet, but stay tuned!
User Reviews
No reviews just yet, but stay tuned!
User Reviews
Average User Rating
Very Quality Mattresses
Excellent return and pick up process. Quality mattresses. We found the firmness levels from the sleep quiz to be a bit firm for us. We dropped down from the Midnight, to the Moonlight, to the Sunset.
Customer Service
Phone Support
Phone support is available at +1(888) 863-2827
Live Online Chat
Available 7 days a week
You can reach their email support through their website
Customer Service
Phone Support
Reach them at +1 (833) 237-3269, available seven days a week from 8 AM to 9 PM ET.
Live Online Chat
Live Chat is available 24/7, seven days a week.
You can find their email on and contact support through their website
Customer Service
Phone Support
You can reach Saatva phone support at (877) 830-0675
Live Online Chat
24/7 live chat available through the website
You can reach the Saatva's email support through the website
Customer Service
Phone Support
Phone support is available at +1(888) 863-2827
Live Online Chat
Available 7 days a week
You can reach their email support through their website
Customer Service
Phone Support
+1 844-973-4717
Live Online Chat
Available online
support@sienasleep.com
Customer Service
Phone Support
831-777-5976
Live Online Chat
10am - 10pm ET, Monday to Sunday
Available directly through site
Final Word
Nectar is an excellent option for those seeking a high-quality, premium mattress at a competitive price point. The Nectar Classic specifically is a great choice as it provides a great balance of comfort and support for most sleepers, especially those under 230 pounds. Additionally, the mattress's excellent motion isolation makes it a good choice for couples. However, it may not be the best option for heavier individuals or stomach sleepers looking for firmer support. Nectar's 365-day trial and lifetime warranty turns all their mattresses into a risk-free investment, Overall, the Classic is a solid choice and Nectar's mattresses offers great value for the price across the board.
Final Word
DreamCloud produces luxury mattresses designed to give you a premium sleeping experience. The DreamCloud Hybrid mattress strikes the perfect balance between firm and cushiony, providing great lumbar, neck, and back support. The DreamCloud Hybrid is a great choice for hot sleepers thanks to the cashmere-blend cover, since it offers moisture-wicking properties.
All DreamCloud mattresses come with a 365-night trial period, allowing you to test them during different seasons throughout the year. Additionally, they all come with a lifetime defect warranty, giving you security and peace of mind. However, it is worth noting that DreamCloud has an initial break-in period of at least 30 days, meaning it isn't possible to return within the first 30 days.
Despite these minor drawbacks, DreamCloud combines comfort, durability, and luxury, making it a strong contender for anyone looking for a cost-effective premium mattress.
Final Word
Saatva has done a great job at making luxurious, supportive mattresses more accessible. While there are more budget-friendly brands, Saatva's beds offer a level of luxury and support even in its simplest models that compete with more high-end options. So if you're looking to spend around $1.5-2k+, the Saatva Classic is worth considering - it offers great pressure relief, awesome edge support, and respectable motion isolation for an all-spring bed. It's also great for hot sleepers!
Saatva's 12 mattress options and customizable firmness mean there's a mattress in stock for every type of sleeper. They've also developed variants specifically for sleepers with back and joint pain.
Final Word
Nectar is an excellent option for those seeking a high-quality, premium mattress at a competitive price point. The Nectar Classic specifically is a great choice as it provides a great balance of comfort and support for most sleepers, especially those under 230 pounds. Additionally, the mattress's excellent motion isolation makes it a good choice for couples. However, it may not be the best option for heavier individuals or stomach sleepers looking for firmer support. Nectar's 365-day trial and lifetime warranty turns all their mattresses into a risk-free investment, Overall, the Classic is a solid choice and Nectar's mattresses offers great value for the price across the board.
Final Word
I found the mattress to be smaller and more firm than I would typically prefer in a mattress, however it's still an affordable mattress brand that offers great motion isolation, pressure relief and responsiveness. Also with their 180-night sleep trial, you can check it out and see for yourself whether it's the right fit for you.
Final Word
Overall Helix offers great mattresses, the Helix Midnight I reviewed get stats across the board, and even if it's not the right match for you, the fact that you can build your own mattress and also try it for 120 nights is really invaluable. The personal touch of the Helix mattress was very soft and comfortable, almost feels like you're sleeping on a nice little cloud.